First a story that my mum told me when I was a kid….
————————————————————————————
Once upon a time in a distant land, there was a village that had a bakery that was famous for delicious pineapple cakes. The cakes tasted sublime and the villagers took pride in that and they owned the bakery together. The cakes attracted people from all the neighboring villages and the pineapple was supplied to the bakery by the farms in that village. The bakery had enough and more advertisement by whoever visited it, at least once and gradually the village prospered.
One year, however the village suffered a drought, there were no rains and gradually the quality of the pineapple took a blight. The bakery still continued to produce cakes except that they dint taste half as good as they had been before. Gradually, customers stopped buying as many cakes. The village people called up on a meeting to discuss about this.
To most of them, the solution seemed very clear – they felt that the competency level of the bakers had come down. Some of them felt, the bakers should be tested before they were handed over this job, some felt there should be a quality analyst at the end of cake making process whose job was to decide if a cake could go on to sale or to be withheld. Some felt the set up had to be revamped. One of them dint wait to point out that he’d seen a ‘modern’ bakery last week, completely equipped, in a far away village that sold pineapple cakes that tasted sublime and felt, for the village to prosper again, they needed modern equipment. All the villagers felt, every solution that was proposed was right and set out on implementing all of them. Some bakers were sacked, some new appointed, new hi-tech equipment and new microwave ovens had been bought before that. A quality analyst was also added.
Two years had passed after that, but the quality of pineapple cakes showed no improvement. The villagers continued to undertake more and more reforms with a desperation to restore the pride of their village’s bakery. As good as their intentions had been, the lack of rains dint help. Nobody even noticed and or even talked about rains.
Third year, there were rains. The quality of pineapple had improved and the cakes started to taste delicious again and the village got back into track. The village heads called up on another meeting to discuss the issue. After much speculation about what had caused the turnabout the villagers agreed on that all these wise heads had always been right and it took a while for their reforms to show results. And they decided, if the quality of the cakes were to go down again, these would be the exact set of rules they’ll have to follow to get it back on track again.
What all of them failed to realize was it was never the system that failed them, it were the rains and as a result, the bakery had not so good pineapples and they apparently wouldn’t taste as good. The pineapples that were supplied was the problem.
————————————————————————————
As with this imaginary village, in our society when a system fails, wise minds inevitably suggest reforms that have to be put in place for the system to have it’s glory restored or achieve glory, if it already hasn’t. The fact that they conveniently ignore is that, systems are not built out of thin air just like that. They are built keeping in mind the social circle they will have to cater to after they have been built and are always built by men who are really wise than mere hypocrites. If an educational system fails, it’s not entirely because of the schools and colleges that are a part of the system, it’s also because of the students that enrolled in it. You always see those students, who have been under the constant supervision of their parents or the elderly and those of whom, that have been taught about the society and it’s values and the value of education or the importance being good – have continuously done well academically, professionally and personally if I might add, socially, as well.
Similarly if you look at a political system, people like Mr. Kalam or Mr. Jayaprakash Narayan (would) have revolutionized the current political proposition for good. You can’t expect an illiterate who was brought up with an emotional, moral and ethical range of a tea spoon to make a difference to the world. And when such systems fail, borrowing thousands of crores of rupees from swiss bank isn’t going to help anyone. It’s surprising how generations after generations of us pay no heed to it, but believe that the systems in place haven’t been offering any incentive for us to grow.
We refuse to acknowledge this fact because, if we start talking about, ‘an illiterate from a poor moral and ethical background’ not being eligible for an elite political post, there are always going to be voices that’ll tell us how we are being indifferent to classes and we inevitably begin to sound like we are talking about race differences. That’s because class still correlates significantly to race in our society. So to suggest that people of generational ‘ethical and moral’ poverty (have got nothing to do with economical and financial statuses here) will frequently have different ethical and social values than those entrenched otherwise – and those poor values don’t really mesh well with the system’s success – is to risk being called a racist.
So, is there no solution to it? … Well, not one immediately….For us to achieve an equivalent society we have to work collectively…
It becomes every parent’s job to educate their kids about moral systems first and then the ethical systems and how to be good and supportive, forgiving to the world around and how to be self-sufficient. Teachers at school will have to take it up from parents and channel that. As we grow up, it becomes our responsibility to co-exist with people around us with the same set of ideologies, as we become elderly it’s a necessity that we imbibe the same value system to our kids and the process should go on. Those who ‘know’ what is right and what is wrong shouldn’t shy away from public. Again, ‘knowing right or wrong’ is tricky. All of us like to believe what we ‘know/say’ is right, but deep down, we inevitably know, what we know is ‘right or wrong’. We should choose to acknowledge our soul and live by that moral ground.
If a system failed, it would not just be ONLY because the system had glitches but also because the people that it catered to were just not good enough for it to sustain. A good system or a society isn’t one which has financial or economical equivalence, but it is the one with moral equivalence.
———————————————————————————-
This is no value embodiment lecture and the opinion expressed is my personal. If it sounded like, I generalized a bit, it’s only because I was trying to project the inherent inconsistencies in us with some intensity but definitely not rubbing off my perspective on the readers. It’s just my mental construction, my idiosyncrasy.
New Cracks