How about Subjective Patriotism?
April 1, 2011 1 Comment
The hype and hysteria that has been surrounding India’s world cup campaign since it’s inception a month ago, makes me puke with disgust. With all due respect to the, “free spirited self-proclaimed” patriots, I think what a nation of one billion people are now subscribing to is fervent aggression. Is it really spirited patriotism when you bash another nation under the guise of “being loyal” to yours? Is it really spirited patriotism when you consider Cricket (I could’ve used the term ‘Sport’ but I want to be more specific) as the ultimate measure of supremacy? Does the theory of patriotism instruct us to not respect other nations at all? Does being loyal to a nation mean, disrespecting other nations? Is sport (In and around subcontinent) playing it’s part to exclude rather than include? Or are people reading too much into it?
I want to specifically bring out the India-Pakistan world cup semifinal here. Each nation flew into a kind of rage against each other while the whole media frenzy added fuel to it. And, it was more than a sport that was talked about. Even if it was sport, since when did sport become a measure of asserting supremacy? And, should there be anyone supreme first up? The animosity between these two nations could be traced back to decades ago. We have fought wars and there’s a sense of dualism in the people from both nations. Yet, I thought we came a long way to curb that animosity, to grow as individuals, to co-exist and co-operate with each other. But sadly, it’s not the case. We, the people from both nations, still have those insecurities and deep down we want to prove to the other that we’re superior than them and we’ll grab everything that comes at us in that process. In the disguise of being loyal and being patriotic, we have been advertising pure hatred and disgust towards each other, which is terribly disturbing.
I don’t get the urge to be patriotic during a cricket match. Most people still can’t make out the difference between being loyal and being patriotic and cheering for their nation. As much as sport has been trying to include nations, the nations inherently have been trying to exclude themselves from the rest. One should realize that Sport is just another lieutenant of the King by name ‘Nation’. It matters not, how much integral a Sport is to it’s people, it’ll always have a winner and a loser. And, accepting defeat gracefully and moving on is something the subcontinent nations haven’t been doing for eons now. We crib, we whine, we blame and then surrender to sombre. We care not, about those fellas on the field who give their 100 percent almost all the time irrespective of the win/loss math. We care not, about the other issues that our nation is currently withstanding. We care not, even if our personal lives are at stake. We need our nation to win and all our personal, civil and societal problems shall be put at bay for a while. All though, such loyalty is overwhelming, more than what is required of it, causes disgust, if not anything. I’m not worked up about Sport alone, but nonetheless the above case serves as a perfect testimony to our repugnant attitudes.
Freedom of Speech/Expression and Social reachability – The two things that have been long thought of as the essential ingredients for a nation to be democratic and developed respectively have become more of a bane than a boon. Facebook and Twitter have been the channels to propagate this divide and the expressiveness of free spirited, self proclaimed, patriots is only adding fuel to this emotional disturbance. Should we behold this sentiment any further, it’s only going to separate us even further. Often times, we hear politicians, calling for “nation building”. If we keep having a strong aversion to nations other than ours, we’d keep building our nation but would never live in a nation that has been built convincingly by it’s people.
I’m not advocating people to shut themselves up behind a closed door. What I’d like to propose is a theory – Subjective Patriotism. One that could help us overcome, some of these issues and bypass some of our behavioral troubles as well. It is our fate as a nation not to have ideologies but be one. By subjective patriotism, what I’m getting at is moral equivalence, the feeling of oneness for the mankind, yet standing up for our nation when it needs us. It helps us establish political stability and social cohesion. Avoid identity formation, avoid stereo typing. Unconditional and unreflective identity formation would degrade us even further both as individuals and as a nation. My notion of subjective patriotism is not to feel love for our own nation. It’s about standing up for our nation when it needs us and being tolerant to the rest of the mankind, always. There are always two sets of ideologies, one that we possess within ourself, one that are derived from the society and the environment around us. It is not always that they are coherent. Subscribing to any of these blindly, with little or no thought takes us nowhere. Subscribing to them, keeping in mind the altruistic needs of the society is what, each one of us as an individual must choose to do, should we be living in a place harmoniously. Rather than grabbing every chance to prove to the world around us that we are supreme as a nation, we should try to use these opportunities to show to the world around us that we can spare a thought or two for the whole of mankind. Now is a time to march towards global harmony and while we attempt to do so, these incessant remarks about other nations sure wouldn’t help us in the cause. The strength of a nation is not measured by what it is, but is measured by how it treats those nations that are less fortunate. So is an individual’s strength of character by how they treat the less fortunate ones. Solidarity people, Solidarity!
I might have made some strong claims here and some of you might even ridicule these claims to be opinionated beliefs or thoughts. And, I’d not be defending this against any of them. If atleast some of you could see a point in it and do your part towards attaining global harmony, the objective of this post would be met.


New Cracks